Eminem and Johnny Cash. They are it. They are originals. Both played large roles in defining their respective generations. I respect them both. If one could categorize individuals these two would be two peas in an iPod.
They are completely different – they are the same:
They rebel
They are bigger than their musical genre
They don’t want to be famous
They came from nothing
They both seemed reluctant to take a stand
Yet they both stand for those who cannot
They are musical outlaw’s – they are subversive…
Eminem is probably seen as much more vulgar than Johnny Cash, but anyone singing back in the late 50′s with lyrics like “I shot a man in Reno just to watch him die” or ”I took a shot of cocaine and shot my woman down” was not okay.*
So why do people listen to them? More specifically why do Christians listen to them? I think it is because like the apostle Paul (as far as I know the Apostle Paul was not known for his musical styling’s) they challenge this world’s status quo; sometimes for better, maybe more often not.
Yet like Paul, they don’t buy the “this world is great” line. They defy the “I’m okay – you’re okay” wisdom of the day. Modernity’s promise of progress hasn’t seemed to reach their ears. They sing for the broken. They seem to shout that they are broken.
And once we see that the world is broken we are drawn to others who see it too, even if they disagree on what it takes to fix it (or whether it can be fixed at all).
Right or wrong, many of my mature Christian friends watch shows like Family Guy, The Daily Show, etc. because these shows are among a rare breed that admit that America is not Camelot. When so few Christians are willing to say the Emperor has no clothes we have to hear it from someone.
That is why I was pleasantly surprised when Catalyst Conference (a Christian conference) opened up their 2010 Atlanta Set with a cover/altered take of “Not Afraid” by Eminem. Not only did they do the song justice. They brought in a voice that although different will stand at the edge of the Empire and shout that “Caesar is not Lord!” I am not a “mushy-feelings” guy, but I had goose-bumps all over and tears in my eyes. I praised our Father in Heaven who hears truth wherever it is brave enough to be uttered.
It has been beautiful to see Christians over the past decade start to again borrow from the philosophers of our day (Just as Paul did in his day – and yes Eminem fits in the category of philosopher) to remind others that we aren’t the only ones watching…wanting change…wanting more…willing to fight…
And I do hope we fight a good fight, fight only worthy battles and have the strength to keep straight the victims from the enemy.
It’s not subversive to bash the outlaws; all of civilized society does that. Subversive is hearing the outlaw’s cries and seeing how civilized society isn’t.
*Most of us think of Johnny Cash and country music as safe, but back then he was not. Leading the charge of “Outlaw Country” Johnny loved America (as do I), but tested her greatly. Sadly many people think of the Apostle Paul and the early church in the same way, but like an outlaw he confronted Rome and fair-weather Christians. He was subversive before you got popular just by being so.
Disclaimer: Johnny Cash had both June and Jesus, which I believe gave him more hope than Eminem, but I don’t blame Eminem for a lack of hope, because without Jesus my hope would be forlorn too. Also, I focused this post more on Eminem, because most Christian’s now readily accept Johnny Cash. All those appearances with Billy Graham must have made him an acceptable modern day Prophet. Or it may be because he is a Prophet of the most appealing kind, a dead one.
PS. If you want to censor them, because you disagree with their message you will only attract more to them. Instead make beautifully subversive music.
Can Christians incorporate truths from people with completely different agendas? What does it say when some Christian’s identify more with people outside the church than those inside?